The Ultimate Guide to Jelly

One of the delicious treats that makes breakfast and mornings complete is a large shmear of jelly. It is perfect for adding on toast, especially when making peanut butter and jelly sandwiches. Jelly might have a different definition depending on where you live, but in North America, it is a clear or translucent fruit spread that is made from sweetened fruit or vegetable juice. Outside North America, jelly is more known as a gelatin-based dessert.

When you go to supermarkets or search online for jellies, you will find a lot of options. They come in different brands and flavors. However, most conventional jellies that you can find in stores are filled with preservatives, stabilizers, and excessive sugars. Based on research, the best jellies should contain just fruit, sugar, and pectin. They should fit your macronutrient needs, and they have to be non-GMO. In fact, you might even get jams and preserves instead of jellies.

If you are looking for a delicious jelly to pair with your toast in the morning, you’re in the right place. Today, we are giving you the ultimate guide to jelly.

Things to Consider When Buying Jellies


Choosing the best jelly in the market can be challenging, but it is more of a personal decision. To help you out, here are some of the essential factors that you can consider to be able to get the best one.

  • The Difference Between Jam, Preserves, and Jellies

Jams, jellies, and preserves are usually used interchangeably. But did you know that they are a bit different from one another? Jelly uses fruit juice as its base while jams and preserves use whole fruit chunks. This means that jams and preserves usually have more fiber and nutrients compared to jellies. However, jams and preserves can also include artificial ingredients and excess sugar.

  • Avoid Jellies with Additives and Stabilizers Besides Pectin

When buying jellies, you need to check the ingredients list. It should include fruit, some sugar, and not much else. One of the things that should be in the ingredients is pectin. It is a type of fiber that is found naturally in all fruits, and it serves as a gelling agent. Fruits like apples, cranberries, and lemons contain higher amounts of pectin. Therefore, when they are turned into jellies, they may not need any additional pectin.

However, most other fruits will likely need added pectin. The best jellies should only have pectin on the ingredient as their gelling agent and nothing more. So, you need to avoid choosing jellies that contain other stabilizers, additives, and gums.

  • Do Not Go for Those with Added Sugars

By its nature, jellies need sugar to have a spreadable, gel-like texture. However, this does not mean that the jelly should be saturated with sugar. You can find some jellies in the market that contain less sugar due to different kinds of pectin. Therefore, when looking at the nutritional label, try to search for a jelly that contains less than 8 grams of added sugar per serving.

You need to be careful in choosing because some jellies have lower sugar content but are added with artificial sweeteners. That’s why it’s also important to check the ingredients to see what kind of sweeteners are added to the jelly, especially because some people are allergic or sensitive to artificial sweeteners like stevia or erythritol.

  • Try to Look for Certifications

It is also best to choose products that have official non-GMO or organic stamps. This is because fruits are often produced using GMOs and pesticides. That’s why its better to avoid any risky contaminations by checking. If you have any allergies or sensitivities, you also need to look for certifications that will meet your needs.

Where to Buy
Mrs. Miller's Homemade Hot Pepper Jelly 18 oz. (3 Jars)
365 Everyday Value, Organic Concorde Grape Jelly, 17.5 oz
Welch's Grape Jelly, 30 oz - Pk of 12
Smucker's Grape Jelly, 32 oz
Newport Jerky Company Coffee Jelly (All Natural, Fat Free, Gluten Free)


The Best Jellies You Can Buy Today

To further help you choose, here are some of the best jellies we found that you might like:

1. Miller’s Homemade Hot Pepper Jelly

This jelly is made of sweet red and green peppers that are combined with spicy jalapeño and chili peppers. You can use this jelly to add sweet spice to sandwiches, wraps, burgers, and chicken. You can also serve it over a block of cream cheese with your favorite crackers for an easy and delicious appetizer or afternoon snack.

2. 365 Everyday Value Organic Concorde Grape Jelly

This jelly is made by combining the juice of organically grown concord grapes, organic cane sugar, and natural fruit pectin, making it a sweet delight. This product is fat-free and sodium-free. It is certified organic and vegan, too. You can spread it on almost anything, from bagels and bread to crackers and toast.

3. Welch’s Concord Grape Jelly

This grape jelly is made with 100% North American grown concord grapes. It does not contain any artificial flavors or colors. This jelly has delicious and bold fruit taste, making it taste goon on toast, crackers, sandwiches, and more.

4. Smucker’s Concord Grape Jelly

This grape jelly is bursting with robust flavor, and it is made with ingredients from natural sources. It does not have artificial colors, no high fructose corn syrup, and no artificial flavors. It is made with real fruit and only five ingredients. It is also certified kosher. You can serve this jelly with a cheese tray of sharp cheddars and blue cheeses. You can also spread it on toast, bread, and crackers.

5. Newport Jerky Company Coffee Jelly

If you are looking for a unique jelly flavor that is perfect for breakfast, then this coffee jelly is perfect for you. It is an all-natural, gluten-free, and fat-free jelly that is handmade in small batches. It is made with nothing but the best freshest ingredients available. It is a must-have for any coffee lover who enjoys breakfast. It is good as a spread on bagels and toast.

Where to Buy
Stonewall Kitchen Red Pepper Jelly, 13 oz. (Pack of 2)
Tiptree Red Currant Jelly, 12 Ounce Jar
Pomegranate Pepper Jelly
Jalapeño Pomegranate Jelly (1)
Newport Jerky Company Elderberry Jelly (All Natural, Fat Free, Gluten Free)


6. Stonewall Kitchen Red Pepper Jelly

This jelly is made with flavorful red peppers, sugar, and a dash of cayenne pepper. It is perfect for breakfast, snack, and as an appetizer. You can serve cream cheese and crackers with a spoonful of this red pepper jelly. It is also a great addition to burgers, and you can use it as a tangy sandwich spread, as well.

7. Tiptree Red Currant Jelly

This jelly is made from the juice of cooked, high-quality fruit. It is gluten-free, made in a nut-free factory, and it is suitable for vegetarians. The juice is first obtained from the fruit by cooking and then sieving through muslin bags, ready to be cooked with sugar before transferring into glass jars. It is perfect for spreading on toast and bread and is also a great condiment and ingredient for some sauces and glazes.

8. Skylake Ranch Pomegranate Pepper Jelly

This jelly is a perfect blend of pomegranate juice with the warmth of jalapeño and habanero peppers. It is best paired with brie, goat cheese, or cream cheese and crackers. You can also use it as a sauce for glazed chicken, pork, or lamb. The ingredients in making this jelly include pomegranate juice, sugar, jalapeño peppers, habanero chiles, pectin, apple cider vinegar, and lemon juice.

9. Western Fare Jalapeño Pomegranate Jelly

This is a delicious and exciting jelly that you can use as glaze, toppings, and sauce. It is delicious on toasted bagels and is also great to serve with different kinds of cheese and crackers. You can also mix it with vegetables, or cook barbecue with it by glazing it on pork, beef, fish, and chicken.

10. Newport Jerky Company Elderberry Jelly

This is an all-natural, gluten-free, and fat-free elderberry jelly. It is a New England classic jelly that is made with the freshest all-natural ingredients. It is also handmade in small batches to ensure taste and quality. It is a good spread for toast, sandwiches, and crackers.

These are some of the best jellies that we can recommend. All of these can surely make your morning or even snack time enjoyable and more flavorful. We hope this guide will help you in finding the best jelly that will suit your taste.