The Most Popular Spreads for Bagels

Who would ignore bagels in the breakfast, especially when topped with their favorite spread? From cream cheese to flavored jellies to peanut butter, there are several ways to jazz up your bagels. And with so many options comes confusion, but don’t worry, we have you covered. Let’s get you through the list of best spreads for bagels and how to pick the right one.

How to Pick Spreads?

Keep in mind how you like it, sweet, salty, sour, or fruity? You can choose from chocolate, cheese, nuts, butter, or jam-based spreads just according to your preference. You can enjoy your bagels with:

1. Margarine or Butter


Margarine/butter is the simplest yet most easily available spread found in almost every house. Just cut your bagel in half, spread some butter or margarine, and have delicious bites.

2. Peanut Butter


Who doesn’t love peanut butter? If you’re not allergic to nuts, peanut butter is a great choice to enjoy with your bagels anytime.

3. Cream Cheese

Did you say cheese? Well, what about spreading some cream cheese over your soft and crunchy bagel? It will taste great. 

4. Jelly and Jam


If you want something fruity and sweet, top-up your favorite bagels with jam or jelly. The combination is so amazing that you will crave it every morning. 

5. Chocolate


Chocolate is everyone’s favorite, and when it comes to having it with your favorite snack, who wouldn’t want it? Several chocolate spreads are available to top up your bagel. 

Considering the different kinds of spreads according to taste, texture, and preference, we bring some best-rated ones to make it easy for you to choose from. 

Our Top Picks

Where to Buy
Nutella Chocolate Hazelnut Spread
Jif Creamy Peanut Butter
Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond Butter
Kraft Philadelphia Cream Cheese
Happy Belly Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread
Philadelphia Spicy Jalapeno Cream Cheese Spread
Land O Lakes, Cinnamon Sugar Butter Spread
Alouette Garlic and Herb Spreadable Cheese
Philadelphia Honey Pecan Cream Cheese Spread

1. Nutella Chocolate Hazelnut Spread

When it comes to the most favorite chocolate spread around the world, Nutella can’t be left behind. It promises to serve the blend of the highest quality of ingredients and is the most popular hazelnut chocolate spread. It includes milk, cocoa, sugar, vanillin, palm oil, hazelnuts, and lecithin. One can’t resist spreading it on bread or bagels due to its creamy, rich texture and appetizing taste. 

Whether you’re a toddler or an adult, you can’t find anything better than Nutella to satisfy your chocolate spread cravings.

2. Jif Creamy Peanut Butter

Jif Creamy Peanut Butter is a perfect choice if you’re a peanut butter lover. Uplift the taste of your roasted bagels with this peanut butter spread. It comes in different sizes for your convenience. Keep a jar in your kitchen for instant breakfast, or keep a pouch in your bag so that it can come in handy whenever you need it while you’re outside. 

For traveling, get a small-sized disposable cup and keep it with you for snack time. Whether you’re at work or outing with your friends or family, Jif Creamy Peanut butter got you covered. 

Its creamy, smooth texture and mouthwatering taste of freshly roasted peanuts are all that you need to love it. You can’t just resist re-stocking it once you have it.

3. Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond Butter

Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond Butter is a vegan-friendly spread. It is a combination of dry and roasted hazelnuts and almonds along with palm oil, sea salt, organic cocoa butter, and cocoa powder. It not only provides you a mouthwatering taste of chocolate but also almond butter which tastes like a perfect blend of flavors.

4. Kraft Philadelphia Cream Cheese

Kraft Philadelphia Cream Cheese is a high-quality dairy product that can be consumed as is or with some other savory item, like bagels. It is an amazing spread for breakfast or snack-time. Store it in your refrigerator to make it last longer and spread it whenever you are hungry.

5. Happy Belly Strawberry Cream Cheese Spread

Imagine the combination of strawberry and cream cheese in a spread topped over your favorite toasted bagels. No artificial flavors or preservatives are added to this spread.

Warning: It is so delicious that some people have even got addicted to its flavor.

6. Philadelphia Spicy Jalapeno Cream Cheese Spread

Not everyone likes their bagels to be sugary and sweet. If you are one of them, this spicy jalapeno cream cheese spread is great to add a spicy kick to your morning bagel. Made with fresh cream and fresh milk, this spread is sure to fulfill your spicy cravings.

7. Land O Lakes, Cinnamon Sugar Butter Spread

The combination of sugar and cinnamon in the butter spread is unique but amazing! If you are up for a sweet treat, let your taste buds taste the flavors of this cinnamon sugar butter spread and bagels. Apart from bagels, you can also use this spread on toast, baked apples, veggies, hot cereal, and much more.

8. Alouette Garlic and Herb Spreadable Cheese

With a perfect blend of artichoke and spinach in cheese, this spread is perfect for your midnight cravings. You can spread it on bagels in the morning and bread at night.

9. Philadelphia Honey Pecan Cream Cheese Spread

If pecans are one of your favorite nuts and bagels are your top morning snack, combine both of them in one and enjoy your day. This cream cheese spread with honey and pecan is an excellent option to fulfill your cravings as well as hunger. You will also feel the chunks of roasted pecans in your cream cheese spread. 

Whether you like to eat cream cheese spread as is with a spoon or topped on a bagel, this is one of the best spreads to go for.



To sort it down a little more, if you are looking for a chocolatey, sweet spread, you can choose between Nutella Chocolate Hazelnut spread and Justin’s Chocolate Hazelnut and Almond Butter combined with almond butter. If you are looking for peanut butter, Jif Creamy Peanut Butter can be a good choice. For a fruity, chunky, and sweet taste, there’s no better pick than Kirkland Signature Organic Strawberry Spread, and if there’s a cream cheese preference, Kraft Philadelphia Cream Cheese is a great answer.